After serving a sentence for a robbery he didn't commit, embittered cowboy Jake Kincaid (Alan Autry) heads to the frontier town of Fairplay looking for revenge and the stolen booty but finds a kindred spirit in resilient townswoman Emma (Kimberlee Autry). Determined to keep his head down while waiting for his man, the fatalistic Kincaid can't help intervening when villainous Quinn and his gang raise trouble among the churchgoing citizenry.