When his usual bag of tricks fails to make an impression on his beautiful new neighbor (Missi Pyle), consummate ladies' man Ted Davis (David DeLuise) decides to turn over a new leaf and embrace his sensitive side in order to win her heart. But when he discovers that transforming himself into a one-woman man has cost him the respect of his friends and co-workers, he sets out to recapture his mojo and once again don the cape of "BachelorMan."